angel investing

How This VC Is Leveling the Playing Field for Multicultural Women

RA-couch-blackframe-1.jpg

By Samantha Miles

This article first appeared on SWAAY

Curious. Dedicated. Provocative. Renata George describes herself in these three words, but truth is, we’d be kidding ourselves stopping here describing this dynamic woman.

An entrepreneur – turned angel investor – turned VC, she’s mastered navigating the ins-and-outs of the entrepreneurial journey. And now, after being dedicated to entrepreneurs for years, George founded Women.vc – a not-for-profit initiative to advance women in the investment industry.

But she isn't stopping there.

She’s also an avid academic, and she’s combined her background in media and journalistic judgment with hard-hitting research to point out the disparity when it comes to women, especially multicultural women, looking for fundraising. While this fact is sadly nothing new for most budding entrepreneurs, George’s approach is truly revolutionary, in that it offers insightful new findings.

We sat down with this incredible disruptor to dish about the groundbreaking work she’s doing for women’s progress.

“I never thought I’d work for the benefit of women,” says George, who describes her brain as “part male,” and adds that most of her friends are men. “I always thought that I would be working with men, but ironically,  since my first business, women were my success story, and it turned out I have something valuable for them to offer.”

Now, she’s become a prominent advocate for women, having proved among other findings, that the net return from women’s portfolio companies is on par with, if not better than, the industry average. For an area dominated by men, this is big news.

Just a taste of what she’s achieved for women in capital markets.

George has been recognized on Forbes USA as one of “The Top Women in Venture Capital and Angel Investing” in 2012. And while that already grounds for one strong and effective female leader, her work goes beyond investment in research, and into the hands of budding entrepreneurs.

So where did it all begin? Coming from a family of doctors, her parents expected her to pursue medicine.

George, however, had other plans. “I was a rebel,” says George, who switched from medical faculty  to financial management after 3 years of studying in Medical  University once she realized medicine is not her calling. Instead, she decided to learn from  a female professor teaching financial management, a rarity at the time.

“When I told my mom what I’d done, she cried for a week,” George recalls. “Later on, however, she said that I did the right choice, and she has been very supportive throughout all my career path”.

In just three years, George graduated from two universities with degrees in financial management and government relationships, having finished both on external basis.

She started working in various media platforms from radio to newspapers, then, established her own publishing house with five magazines in the portfolio, and successfully exited the business. After 10 years in media, George became an angel investor.

Renata George by Sam Saraf

“I went through the hell of being a solo entrepreneur without any investors. But only due to this experience I knew what entrepreneurs need and how I can help them”.

George developed a diverse CV rather quickly, working in government innovation and entrepreneurial pursuits for companies around the world. She soon noticed that many of her portfolio companies started  entering the United States market. “That was a time I realized I could contribute to their success having a broad international experience ,” she says. “At some point, I felt it made sense to move and work in United States.”

George’s countless conversations with American innovators and businessmen, coupled with her multicultural background led her to an epiphany. “I realized I cannot belong to any country,” she says, adding that she had developed an understanding of how many different cultures approached business.

“I realized I can be a connector for [various cultures] to Silicon Valley, because I have traveled so much and learned a lot about people  [as well as] their ways of doing business,” she says. “But it was only in the United States where I figured that I can definitely bring value to diverse groups here, including women and other underrepresented groups.”

Launching a seemingly simple project.

She began by making a list of female investors in the United States, who would serve as touchpoints for women entrepreneurs. She also built up  educational courses and newsletters about venture capital investing.

“Entrepreneurs can learn how venture capitalists think and then speak the same language with them,” says George, who wrote The Manual For Finding A Perfect Mentor For Entrepreneur and Networking Done Classy. “Knowing how your opponent thinks makes a huge difference in negotiations.”

Despite her momentum, there were still voices in George’s life that she felt challenged women’s value.

In an interview a male general partner of a prominent firm said, he cannot find professional women to hire in their firm. “Most of the people took it as an offense to all women, but I personally was not offended. I assumed that he probably meant something different, and decided to dig into the issues.”

With that in mind, George was motivated to prove this opinion wrong or right with  data that hadn’t existed before. “Without data you are just another person with an opinion. I decided to take the other road.,” says George, who used a database to crunch some numbers and evaluate female investors’ success levels. “I wanted to check our performance for myself first of all, so me and several women investors decided to check on how well we’re doing.”

George’s findings, which were released in the summer of 2016, showed what everyone wanted to know, but were afraid to ask female venture investors’ performance was on par with, or better, than men’s. “I can’t do everything, but I prefer doing what I can [with this information],” says George, who was finally armed with proof that there is no logical, or economic reason for stifling females in capital markets. And now, with the dramatic shift in the post election political climate, George’s platform is even more timely. “The social climate made diverse groups, especially those who were born outside the U.S. feel insecure, and we realized we can help them too, so we’re broadening our efforts,” she says.

“It may sound controversial, but when people think about themselves as about a cultural, political or business asset, it’s a whole different approach,” says George, who will also be focusing on education through events and information dissemination to help push the needle towards equality. “We want to switch the diversity agenda from personal to professional. Diversity is not merely about gender, ethnicity or sexuality. Behind every different person, there is a value to the community, society and corporations. The problem, though, is not only leaders should see and believe in it, every single person should recognize his or her value to people around. Once you accept it and learn to articulate it clearly, other people will notice that too.”

These days, George is focused on building on a community of multicultural, trustworthy individuals to learn from and support each other. “We want to show people of different gender, ethnicity and sexuality who made it to the top, who represent those diverse groups by their own example. We also encourage professionals among them to provide complimentary advice and mentorship to address current challenges of those who are still on their way to success, such as immigration issues and civil rights. Of course, we focus on assisting entrepreneurs too. Members of our community  can actually reach out to these professionals and ask for help.”

This initiative is called Diversity.Capital and dedicated to prove that diversity is a political, cultural and business asset. Renata George is one of the co-founders of the project, which is currently opening branches throughout the United States. Iman Oubou, SWAAY founder, was one of the first supporters of Diversity.Capital and helms the community of influencers and shakers in New York.

Essential Read: Impact with Wings

1376ebfb88acfbb48eff81c92f801697.jpeg

We know many of you are sure to be interested in the new anthology book now available for pre-order on Amazon, Impact With Wings: Stories to Inspire and Mobilize Women Angel Investors and Entrepreneurs. We discovered it through the recommendation of Lionesses of Africa, an online community fostering women’s entrepreneurship in Africa.  Read an excerpt of Lionesses' endorsement here, and click through to learn much more about the book and its authors, female impact investors who came together to co-found Wingpact, a global community of investors and entrepreneurs united in a vision to get more women involved in angel investing and entrepreneurship. 

lionessesofafrica.com - Look out for the launch shortly on Amazon of the wonderfully titled Impact With Wings: Stories to Inspire and Mobilize Women Angel Investors and Entrepreneurs. It’s an anthology of personal stories and research written by six female impact investors. This book's purpose is to enlighten and inspire women to step into angel investing and/or entrepreneurship, as it is through investing in each other that we can begin to tip gender imbalances and bring more women forward.

“As women achieve greater financial success, they are looking for projects they can support on behalf of women. Impact with Wings covers a timely topic of interest for more women than ever. It is an extremely valuable and thought-provoking narrative, coupled with practical information on financing.” --- Dr. Marsha Firestone, President/Founder, The Women Presidents’ Organization

The authors of Impact with Wings ask a fundamental question in their book - will you settle for leaving half the world’s wealth on the table? Discovering angel investing transformed the lives of the six women who cofounded Wingpact, a global angel investment and entrepreneur community. In a world where women’s capital remains underused, angel investing—providing money, human capital, and expertise for startup or early-stage companies—offers a potent and often overlooked opportunity for women to impact the future. The authors, all of whom are well-established in the global business and investment community, share their personal stories and insiders’ insights, offering a clarion wake-up call intended to activate new women angel investors and spur women to invest in female-founded companies.

 

Can a rise in female angel investors help close the funding gap?

Photo-by-Tim-Gouw.jpe
managementtoday.co.uk - Research last month from the Women’s Business Council and Deloitte found the proportion of women starting their own firms fell in 2014, despite a record number of new company registrations. There are a range of reasons why – limited access to mentors and networks, lack of self-confidence and a ‘lower appetite for risk’ among some female entrepreneurs.

The lack of female investors out there may also play a part. There are numerous routes to funding but angel investment is still mainly driven by men. Considering we often hear that investors invest in those with characteristics they see in themselves, it’s not surprising to note there can be a pattern to the ‘type’ of businesses that receive funding. A study of 220 UK start-ups by Startup DNA found male entrepreneurs are 59% more likely to secure angel investment.

The situation is improving, though. Women now represent one in seven angel investors in the UK, double the rate in 2008, according to the UK Business Angels Association and the Centre for Entrepreneurs. But that’s still a big disparity. Rich lists might still be populated primarily by men, but the gap is closing. CEBR research back in 2005 suggested women now own 48% of Britain’s assets.

Read more

Angel investors fly high with WOMENA

WOMENA_Fourth-pitch-meeting_03-25-2015_2.jpg
WOMENA_Fourth pitch meeting_03-25-2015_6
WOMENA_Fourth pitch meeting_03-25-2015_6

Women have long been known to control much of family finances, and wealthy women often play important roles as philanthropists and volunteers in their communities. But what isn’t always recognized, especially in the Middle East, is the direct role high-net-worth women can play in investing. One group is working to remedy this by investing in women who will invest in startups—helping female angels spread their wings, and raising up both entrepreneurs and investors in a diverse and growing economy. Launched in November 2014, WOMENA is the MENA region’s first all-female investment group. The group serves as a connection between angel investors and startups, as well as an educational community where members can learn more about seed investment and their potential role in the economy.

Through education, networking, vetting startups and mentoring; WOMENA guides women angel investors through the process of investing.

Middle East Investment Landscape

WOMENA launched during a time of impressive growth of the entrepreneurial and startup ecosystem in the Middle East. Only a few years ago, there was very little investment in innovation and entrepreneurship but in the last couple of years, this growth has begun to explode.

Despite growth in the region, barriers remain for both investors and entrepreneurs. Possible investment funds are much more limited in size and there is a large funding gap past an investment round of $500,000 that needs to be addressed.

But it’s not all doom and gloom. As the infographic below shows, the number of investments more than tripled between 2009 and 2012, and the vast majority of investors expect to invest in the region in the next couple of years.

Women have an important role to play in the Middle East investment landscape, and WOMENA is positioning itself as an avenue for women to become involved. With case studies like Springboard, there is consistent evidence that women can made a significant impact on the landscape.

MENA-Investment-Landscape
MENA-Investment-Landscape

Making investing accessible

WOMENA_Chantalle Dumonceaux
WOMENA_Chantalle Dumonceaux

Womena’s cofounders, Elissa Freiha and Chantalle Dumonceaux, certainly know about education and research. From their early days of collaboration, Freiha and Dumonceaux knew they wanted to create something to fill a need in the investing community. They found there was a lack of a platform for women to invest in startup companies and to play a direct role in growing the economy.

A lack of education—combined with being outnumbered in a field that is predominantly male, and often feeling too intimidated to ask many questions—left many women out of investing circles completely. Freiha and Dumonceaux wanted to forge a way to make investing accessible to women—and to utilize women as the indispensable member of the economy they knew them to be.

WOMENA: Innovation, Investment and Inclusion

Their solution was to serve as a facilitator between high-net-worth women who were interested in angel investing, and startup businesses in the Middle East that had high potential. WOMENA discovers entrepreneurs who need funds to grow their businesses. They research the companies and interview the entrepreneurs to determine the viability of the businesses, and once a month they host a meeting in which two or three startups pitch to WOMENA's investors. The meetings are held in inviting locales like an art gallery, entrepreneurship center and a garden, but they're far from casual meetings.

Perhaps most importantly, WOMENA aims to make investing the inspirational, fun, connection-driven, human experience they know it can be.

Angel investors

WOMENA_Launch_10-01-2014
WOMENA_Launch_10-01-2014

WOMENA members are proactive women who want to impact their community and be involved in economic growth. The organization must invite each investor to join, so it's a select and elite group: Members must have the funds to withstand the risk of investment, and they must pay an annual membership fee and commit to a minimum investment. But most of all WOMENA looks for potential investors to be excited and motivated to use their resources—financial, networking and personal—to bolster the economy and encourage entrepreneurs.

Members attend meetings where pre-screened entrepreneurs present their businesses for funding, after which WOMENA facilitates the entire investment process from deal source to deal close while educating members with individual and group coaching.

The more a member invests in presenting companies, the more value they get out of their membership. Members are asked to invest in at least one company per year. The minimum ticket is $5,000 USD (approximately 18,000 AED). It is suggested that members make three to five investments per year to diversify their portfolios and mitigate risk. In the first year of membership, members are not required to invest. After the first year, WOMENA requests that members utilize their membership to the fullest extent possible and participate in at least one investment per year.

Entrepreneurs

WOMENA_Elissa Freiha
WOMENA_Elissa Freiha

Unlike angel investors, WOMENA welcomes entrepreneurs who are men or women, but they have stringent standards for who they work with—all aimed at nurturing the startup ecosystem and each member of their process.

Entrepreneurs receive access to industry leaders, start-up service providers and other crucial contacts for fledgling companies. WOMENA is looking for companies that are based in the MENA region and are raising $150,000 to $750,000 USD (550,000 – 2,750,000 AED) to sustain them for twelve to eighteen months. Among other qualities the group seeks are companies that are highly scalable and innovative and those that solve a big problem in an underserved market.

Entrepreneurs can find an application form online. Once WOMENA receives the initial application, they will ask for more information and set up a phone call to discuss the company and conduct initial due diligence. Once this is complete, entrepreneurs will be invited to apply. Approximately 5 percent of applicants are selected to present in front of members.

WOMENA seeks businesses that can multiply an investment by a factor of ten over a five-year period. Companies that fit the bill tend to be in fields including ecommerce, software, life sciences, telecommunication, energy, wholesale services and retail services.

WOMENA_Second pitch meeting_01-24-2015_1
WOMENA_Second pitch meeting_01-24-2015_1

Making connections, growing businesses

WOMENA offers more to entrepreneurs than funding. The organization believes in more than funding: They operate on the conviction that through investment in the right entrepreneurs and startups, investors—including women—can help create jobs, promote economic growth, and make a difference. This conviction translates to devotion from the angel investors that takes many forms.

Members of the group have networks and resources they use to help new companies. Collectively, members can help entrepreneurs with business development, relationships with suppliers and distributors, marketing, finding employees, strategy and almost any other resources or network needed in the region. These are more than social gatherings. They're movements.

Investors receive more than facilitated deals, too. In partnership with financial institutions, corporates, and development organizations, WOMENA hosts half-day workshops for high-net-worth women and other aspiring angel investors covering all facets of angel investment. To help foster the startup ecosystem, WOMENA also provides quarterly half-day workshops to educate entrepreneurs on fundraising.

Ladies Who Launch

WOMENA_Sixth pitch meeting_06-15-2015_7
WOMENA_Sixth pitch meeting_06-15-2015_7

The platform got its official start November 1, 2014, when almost 50 leading women from across the Middle East gathered in Dubai to celebrate the launch of WOMENA at their inaugural event, “Ladies Who Launch.” The event had guests travelling from as far away as Silicon Valley and Turkey, from many different industry sectors and cultures.

The launch was followed shortly by the first pitch meeting December 10, where Kamal Hassan and Bern Shen also gave short presentations to members on angel investing; and companies Melltoo, Feesheh and Eventtus presented to members. Within a few weeks, Melltoo had received an investment.

A second pitch meeting was held January 24 at the Art Sawa Gallery in Al Quoz, Dubai; where members heard from AlemHealth and Apptuto. February 21 saw the their pitch meeting, also at the gallery, where attendees heard from Crowd Analyzer and MediaWave. The gathering drew record attendance despite a sandstorm sweeping the city. WOMENA, like the women it serves, had become an unflagging force.

The first woman angel

WOMENA-Logo
WOMENA-Logo

Even the organization’s logo has an entrepreneurial success story behind it: the number five three times, for 555 C.E., the birth year of Sayyida Khadija, or Khadija the Great.

Khadija came from a rich family in Saudi Arabia. A quick study in finance and business, she took over her father’s business after he passed away, started her own business, and flourished in a male-dominated economy and society. She was married three times and widowed twice, all the while maintaining her generosity and unflagging support for those around her, before she met Mohammed. It was a meeting of hearts and minds, and though Mohammed offered to support his wife financially, Khadija preferred to wed for his nobility, loyalty and love. She remained financially independent throughout their marriage—for 25 years—and became the Prophet Mohammed’s first follower.

WOMENA_Third pitch meeting_02-01-2015_1
WOMENA_Third pitch meeting_02-01-2015_1

It might be a legendary example, but Khadija’s story should sound familiar to many angel investors in the MENA region: She loved her friends and family, served her community, and ran a business empire. Her strengths as a woman in her community became her strengths as a businesswoman and investor.

Calling her “a true role model for the ages,” WOMENA’s website also notes: “She was a wife, a mother, a philanthropist, an entrepreneur, an angel investor and an inspiration.”

Working together; Freiha, Dumonceaux and countless other women from the region are inspirations for a new day—and a new way of seeing investing in the Middle East.

To learn more, visit WOMENA's website, like them on Facebook, or follow them on Twitter and Instagram.

#IAmVested in #TheStateOfWomen #YVEST